It’s hard to decide Goose Creek candles vs Bath and Body Works, which is better?

Bath and Body Works candles have always been a popular choice for those looking for a high-quality, scented candle. However, Goose Creek candles are quickly gaining popularity, with some people saying they are even better than Bath and Body Works candles.

So, to end this debate, I have tried both brands of candles to see which one works well when it comes to scent, wick, and longevity. 

Keep going to get more useful information.

Goose Creek vs Bath and Body Works: Overview

It can be helpful to have some basic information about each brand before you begin the examination.

AspectGoose Creek CandlesBath and Body Works
Brand PhilosophyFocuses on high-quality, highly scented candles and home fragrance productsEmphasizes a wide range of scented body care, home fragrance, and personal care products
Key ProductsOffers a diverse range of scented candles, wax melts, and home fragrance productsProvides a comprehensive range of body care, home fragrance, and personal care products with a focus on seasonal scents
Fragrance OptionsFeatures a wide variety of unique, highly fragrant scents with long-lasting throwOffers a diverse range of seasonal and signature scents across its product lines, with frequent new releases
Target AudienceTargets individuals seeking high-quality, strong-scented candles and home fragrance productsCaters to consumers interested in fragrant body care, home fragrance, and seasonal scents
PackagingUtilizes simple, functional packaging with clear labelingFeatures colorful, vibrant packaging with a focus on seasonal themes and collections
PricingPositioned as a mid-range, accessible brandPositioned as a mid-range, accessible brand
Popular ProductsGoose Creek Candles Large Jar Candles, Goose Creek Wax MeltsBath and Body Works 3-Wick Candles, Bath and Body Works Fine Fragrance Mists
Marketing ApproachEmphasizes high-quality, strong-scented candles and wax melts with a focus on fragrance experienceFocuses on seasonal scents and promotions, with a focus on fragrance experiences
AvailabilityAvailable through the brand’s website and select retailersWidely available through standalone stores, malls, and online platforms

Goose Creek Candle Company

Goose Creek Candles Company

Goose Creek Candle was started by Chuck Meece in Liberty, Kentucky, in 1998. They are a family-owned company.

They don’t include any banned or unsafe chemicals in their formulas. These candles can be lit in the home of customers without releasing toxic substances.

Despite their high fragrance content, Goose Creek candles are significantly cheaper than other candle companies in the same category.

Bath & Body Works Company

Bath & Body Works Company 

Les Wexner founded Bath & Body Works in 1990. Although the original headquarters were in New Albany, Ohio, USA, the company is still active in Reynoldsburg. The Wexner family has since sold Bath & Body Works, but the company still retains a loyal following.

BBW uses a similar amount of fragrance oils as Goose Creek Candle, but their ingredients may not be as eco-friendly. They don’t specify if it is triple the industry standard.

The rumor is that BBW candles cost more than GC. However, I have not found this to be true. Their 3-Wick candles are the same price, and Goose Creek Candle’s 7 oz option costs USD 1 less than Bath & Body Works.

Are Goose Creek Candles Better than Bath and Body Works?

Is Goose Creek Candle better than Bath & Body Works?

Both companies also sell body and bath care products. You can see that Bath & Body Works has many more options for these categories.

READ ALSO  Is Aveeno Safe For Tattoos?

Goose Creek Candle

  • Foaming hand soap
  • Body lotion
  • Shower gel
  • Hand cream

Bath & Body Works

  • Body scrubs
  • Body washes and shower gels
  • Body lotions
  • Fine fragrance mists
  • Bubble bath
  • Bath fizzies
  • Bar soaps
  • Hand creams
  • Lip gloss and lip balms
  • Cologne

However, this makes sense since BBW does not include the word candle within its company name, while GC does. It is obvious which company focuses its product development.

Candle Size Comparisons

Let’s focus on candles as the central overlap between these companies. Goose Creek is able to surpass Bath & Body Works in this area with one more size option.

Both companies pour their candles in glass containers and jars. The jars can be reused in various DIY projects and holders if they are appropriately cleaned. The 24 oz jars look similar to Yankee Candle’s originals.

Do Goose Creek candles fit in Bath and Body Works candle holders?

If you’re looking for a 3-wick candle holder that will fit any brand of candle, look no further than the Bath & Body Works candle holder! 

Bath and Body Works Candle Holder

The 3-wick candle holder is specifically designed for Bath & Body Works 3-wick candle holder, but surprisingly, it also fits in other candle brands.

I just checked, and the dimensions of my Goose Creek 3-wick candle are identical to the BBW 3-wick candle, so it fits perfectly in the BBW holder.

Fragrance Comparisons

Goose Creek Candle uses only fragrances that are on the International Fragrance Association (IFRA) safelists.

Bath & Body Works doesn’t make that claim, as far as I know. However, I look at their ingredients list, I see that they do not use toxic ingredients in any of their candles.

However, neither company divulges all of its ingredients. Companies can choose not to share specific components of proprietary product recipes due to privacy protections.

Both companies use essential oils and fragrance oils in all of their aromatherapy candle lines. Aromatherapy candles cannot be made without essential oils.

According to my knowledge, each company has close to or slightly more than 100 candle fragrances in all of its collections.

Also read: Are Bath And Body Works Candles Toxic 2022?

Comparison of Wicks & Wax

Both companies use lead-free candles. Goose Creek Candle sometimes refers to its wicks being 100% cotton, but it’s not consistent. I don’t know if they use different wicks.

Depending on the wax mix, some candle companies use different wicks for different fragrances. This ensures that the candles burn evenly. This might be true here.

There are many similarities between the two companies in terms of wax. Both companies use a proprietary soy wax blend. Bath & Body Works’ blend contains soy, palm, and paraffin waxes. Goose Creek doesn’t specify what additional wax types are in their combination.

Goose Creek Candle claims that they use only natural ingredients, but I didn’t see any evidence to support that claim. They frequently use terms such as “clean” or “health-conscious” on their website.

Their products are also vegan, cruelty-free, and contain no parabens and toxins. They don’t link to the candle ingredients on each product, unlike BBW. This means that it is impossible to determine if their products are genuinely natural.

Are Goose Creek candles made with soy wax?

At Goose Creek, they make 3-wick candles out of a soy wax blend that has 3x the fragrance of traditional candles. Each candle quickly fills any room with fragrance, small or large. 

Most of their candles are made with premium-quality paraffin wax blends because it burns clean and creates a wonderful base for all the delightful oils and botanicals that can be added to the wax to create unique scents.

Goose Creek Candle

Paraffin wax is ideal for long burn times and doesn’t produce any excess soot or smoke. 

READ ALSO  Is Original Chloe Perfume Discontinued

Additionally, it’s completely safe to use indoors as it won’t emit any harmful chemicals into your home. That’s why it’s a top choice for all sorts of decorative and aromatherapy candles.

What kind of wax are Bath & Body Works candles made out of?

According to their website, Bath & Body Works uses two types of wax for their candles – vegetable and paraffin. 

Their formulas’ main ingredients are vegetable wax, paraffin wax, and soy. 

It’s said that the brand’s “Signature Collection Candles” are paraffin-free and contain a blend of vegetable and soy wax. They don’t specify what type of vegetable wax is used in their products.

While the average Bath and Body Works candle might not be toxic, they certainly aren’t harmless – and more people are beginning to ask about safe, all-natural alternatives to this popular candle brand. 

Most scented candles on the market contain potentially harmful or toxic ingredients like paraffin and formaldehyde. 

Not to mention, many of these candles also contain unnatural chemical scents that are released into the air when they’re burned. 

So, if you’re looking for a safer and more natural option for your next candle purchase, be sure to do your research!

How long do Goose Creek candles last?

The answer to how long a candle lasts depends on several factors, such as what it’s made of, its size, and its shape. 

For instance, candles come in many different sizes and forms, from tall pillar candles to tiny tea lights. 

Obviously, they all burn for varying periods of time. Different manufacturing methods and additives also affect burn time.

Goose Creek candles are known for their long-lasting burn time, and their three-wick candles are no exception. These candles are made with thick wicks, quality materials, and regular shapes to ensure a long-lasting burn. 

The 14.5-ounce candles have a burn time of at least 35 hours, and the smaller 7-ounce single-wick candles have a burn time of up to 45 hours.

How long does a Bath and Body Works candle last?

These soy-based candles have a burn time of up to 45 hours, so you can enjoy their room-filling fragrance for a long time. 

I usually burn them for at least three hours at a time, and they last for 30 hours or more. However, the actual burn time of a candle can vary depending on how it is used. 

For example, if you burn a Bath and Body Works candle continuously for 25 hours, it may not last as long as if you burned it for 4 hours at a time.

Bath and Body Works Candle

Bath and Body Works candles claim to have a burn time of 25-45 hours. 

Still, many reviews suggest that the single-wick candle burns for significantly longer than the triple-wick candle. 

If you’re looking for a candle that will last longer, opting for a single-wick candle is a wiser choice. 

However, it’s worth noting that the triple-wick candles tend to have a stronger scent.

Are goose creek candles toxic?

Although Goose Creek candles have been determined to be non-toxic and as safe to burn as other candles, some people remain wary of them because they are made with paraffin wax. 

Paraffin wax is a petroleum-based byproduct that comes from crude oil, and because of this, some people fear that there may be toxic elements to it. 

However, there is no evidence to support this claim. While there are always hazards associated with open flames, there are no unusual dangers you need to worry about with Goose Creek candles.

Goose Creek is dedicated to creating candles that burn clean and don’t release harmful chemicals into the air. They use cotton wicks because lead is known to be harmful to health. 

This commitment to providing their consumers with safe, clean-burning candles is another way Goose Creek works to create a healthier world.

READ ALSO  Can You Use Body Lotion On Face?

Best Goose Creek Candles

Goose Creek Sugared Donut Candle

The 444 five-star reviews on the Sugared Donut candle show that it’s one of the company’s most popular scents. Who could resist a good donut-scented candle?

Goose Creek Vanilla Tobacco & Amber

The warm Vanilla Tobacco and Amber fragrance is the perfect way to make your home smell like a cozy log cabin. With just a hint of sweetness, this fragrance is perfect for burning on cold days.

Goose Creek Watermelon Lemonade

Goose Creek candles are known for their “high-intensity fragrances,” and the Watermelon Lemonade scent is perfect for summer. This is the candle for you if you’re looking for a sweet, summery fragrance.

Goose Creek candles where to buy?

You may purchase Goose Greek candles on their official website or on Amazon.

Best Bath and Body Works Candles

Eucalyptus Spearmint

Bath & Body Works Eucalyptus Spearmint

Many reviewers have noted how much they enjoy the balanced scent of this candle, which offers eucalyptus and spearmint aromas in equal measure. 

After just a few moments of lighting the candle, I truly felt more at ease. It made my home smell like a luxurious spa – without the expensive price tag!

Mahogany Teakwood Intense Candle

Mahogany Teakwood Intense Candle

Mahagony Teakwood Intense is my favorite Bath & Body Works candle by far. 

I would even say that it’s one of the best-smelling candles that Bath & Body Works has ever made. 

If this is your go-to scent, chances are you’re single and looking for a man, or you’re a bachelor looking to impress your female friends with good vibes and a good smell.

Midnight Blue Citrus 

Bath and Body Works Midnight Blue Citrus 

Don’t let the name “Citrus Grove” fool you. 

This candle won’t make your home smell like a tropical paradise. The amber notes help offset the citrusy fragrance, making it a more fresh and welcoming scent.

Goose Creek vs Bath and Body Works Candles: Are There Any Differences?

These four points seem to make Goose Creek Candle stand apart from BBW.

  • They use three times as much fragrance oil.
  • Customers praise them for their unique scents.
  • A strong scent is released when the candle is lit.
  • Over time, candles continue to burn evenly.

Customers seem to be most satisfied with this last point. Many Bath & Body Works customers complained that their candles didn’t burn as well over time, and they smelled stronger towards the end. This made them feel like the purchase was a waste.

Takeaway: If you consider all other factors equal, Goose Creek Candle may be a better choice in terms of value. The candle will have a robust and consistent fragrance that will last until the end.

Are Bath and Body Works candles high quality?

Bath & Body Works candles are well-known for their quality fragrances and addicting scents. The candles disperse the fragrance widely without being overpowering, making them a go-to for many people. 

My research has found that Bath & Body Works candles have high-quality fragrances and a clean burn.

Their candles are incredible! The fragrance is strong and lingers even after the candle is extinguished. Almost everyone who comes into my home comments on how good it smells. 

The only downside is that it seems to burn quickly. I burn it only a few times a week, and it lasted around 10 sessions. The burn quality was excellent – no wick issues, tunneling, and soot. 

I was delighted with the overall quality of these candles. Some had stronger scents than others, but they were all high-quality.

Are Goose Creek candles clean burning?

Goose Creek candles are clean burning, meaning they don’t produce excess smoke or soot. They’re also made without dangerous chemicals, and each candle has a lead-free, 100% cotton wick. 

Goose Creek candles are safe for use in your home, and their aromatherapy candles are approved by the IFRA (International Fragrance Association).

Goose Creek candles are made with 100% cotton wicks, which are American-made and lead-free. 

These candles burn clean and even, and each one is said to contain 3 times the fragrance of competitor’s candles. Goose Creek candles are also said to be healthier and safer for customers than other brands.

Bath and Body Works vs Goose Creek: Final Thoughts

Both brands of candles have their own advantages. BBW candles are known for their quality and scent. However, Goose Creek candles are a close second and sometimes offer a better price. Hope that this article can help you easily decide which is the most suitable for you.

Categorized in: